| 2010 |
Alec Robbins (Offensive) |
Scott |
| 2010 |
Austin Juniet (Offensive) |
NCC |
| 2010 |
Rob Poehlmann (Defensive) |
Ryle |
| 2009 |
Alec Robbins (Offensive) |
Scott |
| 2009 |
Garrett Justice (Defensive) |
Cov. Cath. |
| 2008 |
Eric Froschauer (Offensive) |
Ryle |
| 2008 |
Chris Grosser (Defensive) |
NCC |
| 2007 |
Jordan Parks (Offensive) |
Campbell Co. |
| 2007 |
David Roy (Offensive) |
NCC |
| 2007 |
Jordan Hilgefort (Defensive) |
St. Henry |
| 2006 |
Jimmy Uebel (Offensive) |
Bishop Brossart |
| 2006 |
Dustin Zink (Defensive) |
NCC |
| 2005 |
Jim Uebel (Offensive) |
Bishop Brossart |
| 2005 |
Kyle Frimming (Defender) |
Bishop Brossart |
| 2004 |
Jarrod Willoughby - Offender |
Ryle |
| 2004 |
Brad Rhoden - Defender |
Bishop Brossart |
| 2003 |
Josh Coldiron - Offensive POY |
Boone Co. |
| 2003 |
Phillip Schultz - Defensive POY |
Holy Cross |
| 2002 |
Josh Coldiron |
Boone County |
| 2001 |
Jeff Hughes |
Holmes |
| 2000 |
Eric Kleiman |
St. Henry |
| 1999 |
Rob Hassman |
Highlands |
| 1998 |
Tony Becker |
St. Henry |
| 1997 |
Robbie Golsch |
Dixie Heights |
| 1996 |
Justin Hanks |
Cov. Cath. |
